Understanding epistemic uncertainty in large-scale coastal flood risk estimates for present and future climates

An upscaling of flood risk assessment frameworks beyond regional and national scales has taken place during recent years, with a number of large-scale models emerging as tools for hotspot identification, support for international policy-making and harmonization of climate change adaptation strategies. There is, however, limited insight on the scaling 10 effects and structural limitations of flood risk models and, therefore, the underlying uncertainty. In light of this, we examine key sources of epistemic uncertainty in the Coastal Flood Risk (CFR) modelling chain: (i) the inclusion and interaction of different hydraulic components leading to extreme sea-level (ESL); (ii) inundation modelling; (iii) the underlying uncertainty in the Digital Elevation Model (DEM); (iv) flood defence information; (v) the assumptions behind the use of depth-damage functions that express vulnerability; and (vi) different climate change projections. The impact of these uncertainties to 15 estimated Expected Annual Damage (EAD) for present and future climates is evaluated in a dual case study in Faro, Portugal and in the Iberian Peninsula. The ranking of the uncertainty factors varies among the different case studies, baseline CFR estimates, as well as their absolute/relative changes. We find that uncertainty from ESL contributions, and in particular the way waves are treated, can be higher than the uncertainty of the two greenhouse gas emission projections and six climate models that are used. Of comparable importance is the quality of information on coastal protection levels and DEM 20 information. In the absence of large-extent datasets with sufficient resolution and accuracy the latter two factors are the main bottlenecks in terms of large-scale CFR assessment quality.

VOUSDOUKAS Michail;  BOUZIOTAS Dimitrios;  GIARDINO Alessio;  BOUWER Laurens;  MENTASCHI Lorenzo;  FEYEN Luc; 

2018-10-04

COPERNICUS GESELLSCHAFT MBH

JRC111499

1561-8633 (online),   

https://www.nat-hazards-earth-syst-sci.net/18/2127/2018/,    https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC111499,   

10.5194/nhess-18-2127-2018 (online),