Purpose
A growing number of studies have examined whether Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems can support imaging-based diagnosis of COVID-19-caused pneumonia, including both gains in diagnostic performance and speed. However, what is currently missing is a combined appreciation of studies comparing human readers and AI.
Methods
We followed PRISMA-DTA guidelines for our systematic review, searching EMBASE, PUBMED and Scopus databases. To gain insights into the potential value of AI methods, we focused on studies comparing the performance of human readers versus AI models or versus AI-supported human readings.
Results
Our search identified 1270 studies, of which 12 fulfilled specific selection criteria. Concerning diagnostic performance, in testing datasets reported sensitivity was 42–100% (human readers, n = 9 studies), 60–95% (AI systems, n = 10) and 81–98% (AI-supported readers, n = 3), whilst reported specificity was 26–100% (human readers, n = 8), 61–96% (AI systems, n = 10) and 78–99% (AI-supported readings, n = 2). One study highlighted the potential of AI-supported readings for the assessment of lung lesion burden changes, whilst two studies indicated potential time savings for detection with AI.
Conclusions
Our review indicates that AI systems or AI-supported human readings show less performance variability (interquartile range) in general, and may support the differentiation of COVID-19 pneumonia from other forms of pneumonia when used in high-prevalence and symptomatic populations. However, inconsistencies related to study design, reporting of data, areas of risk of bias, as well as limitations of statistical analyses complicate clear conclusions. We therefore support efforts for developing critical elements of study design when assessing the value of AI for diagnostic imaging.
KRIZA Christine;
AMENTA Valeria;
ZENIE' Ibaa Alexandre;
PANIDIS Dimitrios;
CHASSAIGNE Hubert;
URBAN LOPEZ Patricia;
GRIESINGER Claudius;
HOLZWARTH Uwe;
SAUER Aisha Vanessa;
REINA Vittorio;
2021-11-30
ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD
JRC125238
0720-048X (online),
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0720048X2100509X?via%3Dihub,
https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC125238,
10.1016/j.ejrad.2021.110028 (online),
