The last thing on your mind: Recall bias in EU income measurement

This paper studies the soundness and consistency of income measurement in the EU-SILC, the main household survey of the European Union. By comparing income data collected at different times of the year, I show that households exhibit strong recall bias when asked to report their income for the previous calendar year. In particular, retrospective valuations are skewed towards respondents’ contemporaneous income at the time of the interview. Given large heterogeneity in data collection schedules, this present bias has serious consequences for the stability, reliability and international comparability of income statistics across the EU. Microdata analysis from 2007-2021 shows that income self-reports diverge by more than 10% across sampling quarters on average, which seriously distorts official statistics, income trends and poverty estimates in several member states. These findings call for the harmonisation of EU-SILC data collection periods, more extensive use of registers, and a thorough review of related EU social statistics.

MENYHERT Balint; 

2025-11-12

WILEY

JRC143429

1475-4991 (online),   

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/roiw.70030,    https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC143429,   

10.1111/roiw.70030 (online),