A Novel Metho to Apply Importance and Sensitivity to MUltiple Fault-Trees

The unavailability/frequency analysis of critical failure states of complex industrial systems is normally conducted by using the Fault-tree methodology. The number of Fault-trees describing the system is given by the number of system's failure states (i.e. Top-events). For each Top-event characterised by unacceptable occurrence probability, some design improvements shoud be made. Importance and Sensitivity Analysis (ISA) is normally applied to identify the weakest parts of the system. By selecting these parts for design improvement, the overall improvement of the system is made more effective. In current practice, ISA is normally applied sequentially to all Fault-trees. The sequence order is subjectively selected by the analyst, based on several criteria as for instance the severity of the associated Top-event. This approach has the clear limitation of not ensuring the identification of the most cost-effective design solution to improve safety. The present paper describes an alternative approach which consists of concurrently analyzing all relevant system's Fault-trees with the objective of overcoming the above limitations and to propose the most cost-effective solution. In addition, the proposed method extends the ISA application to 'over-reliable' system functions, if any, on which the reliability/maintainability characteristics of the involved components can be relaxed, with a resulting cost saving. The overall outcome of the analysis is a uniformly protected system, which satisfies the predefined design goals. A point to note is that the overall cost of the analysis of the proposed approach is significantly lower if compared with the sequential case.

CONTINI Sergio;  FABBRI Luciano;  MATUZAS Vaidas; 

2010-09-21

ELSEVIER SCI LTD

JRC56322

0950-4230,   

www.elsevier.com/locate/jlp,    https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC56322,   

10.1016/j.jlp.2010.05.004,