The importance of commutability of reference materials used as calibrators: the example of ceruloplasmin

BACKGROUND: Different methods for ceruloplasmin tend to give different results in external quality assessment schemes. During the production of the certified reference material ERM-DA470k/IFCC discrepant measurement results were also found for ceruloplasmin measured with different methods, and consequently the protein could not be certified in the material. METHODS: We performed a commutability study with 30 serum samples and the reference materials ERMDA470, ERM-DA470k/IFCC, and ERM-DA472/IFCC, using 6 different methods. Data were analyzed according to the CLSI Guideline C53-A to assess whether the reference materials had the same behavior as the serum samples with respect to measurement results obtained with combinations of the methods used. RESULTS: Measurement results from different methods showed a good linear correlation for the serum samples. ERM-DA470 showed marked noncommutability for certain combinations of methods. ERMDA470k/IFCC and ERM-DA472/IFCC were commutable for more combinations of methods. The lack of commutability of ERM-DA470 for certain combinations of methods correlates with results from the UK National External Quality Assessment Service showing discrepancies between results from these methods. For serum stored in the presence of sodium azide the results from different methods are essentially equivalent. CONCLUSIONS: Ceruloplasmin in ERM-DA470 is a fully documented example of a situation in which, due to lack of commutability, the use of a common material for calibration did not lead to harmonization .

ZEGERS Ingrid;  BEETHAM Robert;  KELLER Thomas;  SHELDON Joanna;  BULLOCK David;  MACKENZIE Finlay;  TRAPMANN Stefanie;  EMONS Hendrik;  SCHIMMEL Heinz; 

2013-09-23

AMER ASSOC CLINICAL CHEMISTRY

JRC79021

0009-9147,   

http://www.clinchem.org/content/59/9/1322,    https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/handle/JRC79021,   

10.1373/clinchem.2012.201954,